vote up 1 vote down
star

I recently took some Chinese medical herbs that promised to remove my body heat and cleanse my chi. I don't believe there is such a thing as chi, but the cocktail of herbs looked nice so i took it. Within 24 hours, the stuff really worked. My skin turned red and i could feel heat on the surface. Now i am cool like a cucumber.

I never really thought of it, but what could chi actually be ? I doubt there is a physical measurable life-force. Could Chi be a misunderstanding of other body functions ?

I am guessing the herbs actually clean the lymph nodes, but my wife insists, is CHI..

flag

1 Answer

vote up 1 vote down

Your question implies there is no other explanation for your skin turning warm and flushed, typical if the blood vessels are relaxed, and later cool, expected if they returned to normal by way of contrast or were contracted reducing surface blood flow. You also say 'it worked', but have no measure of what working means. So you got warm and then cool; is that all you require to consider the herbs did their job? How do you tell cleansed Chi from dirty Chi? How do you know they did anything beyond making you feel warm and cool, which in itself is a subjective assessment?

I'm not a doctor, so others may have a medical opinion, but I will say that there are likely other explanations for the effects you see that have nothing to do with mysterious life forces and everything to do with the physiology of your body and the actions of various chemicals contained in the herbs you consumed. I certainly doubt that they clean lymph nodes, and if all your body heat was removed you would be dead.

If you list the herbs, then that would allow a more in-depth analysis, but failing that you should assume the answer that fits with existing knowledge of biology and medicine versus an answer that requires invisible life forces.

link|flag

Your Answer

Get an OpenID
or

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.